Dr. Bhavana Sharma, Assistant Professor of Law, School of Legal Studies, Himachal Pradesh University Regional centre, Dharamshala, HP
Abstract: Indian juvenile justice system is based on the reformative philosophy that children in conflict with law require care, protection, rehabilitation, and reintegration rather than punitive treatment. But in reality, the juvenile justice institutions fails to follow these principles and thus there is a significant gap between reformative ideals and institutional realities. In this paper, the researcher has tried to analyse the implementation of juvenile justice administration in India with special reference to observation homes, special homes, rehabilitation mechanisms, counselling facilities, educational access, and post-release reintegration. In this study, both doctrinal and empirical methodologies have been adopted and data have been collected through analysis of statutory provisions, judicial decisions, government reports, NCRB data, and responses collected from juveniles, probation officers, legal practitioners, and social workers. And the study shows that there are structural deficiencies such as overcrowding, inadequate counselling infrastructure, shortage of trained personnel, delay in inquiry proceedings, stigmatization, and lack of vocational opportunities within juvenile institutions. And thus the researcher proposes that juvenile justice administration in India requires stronger rehabilitative infrastructure, specialized training, psychological support systems, and community-based reintegration models to transform reformative theory into meaningful institutional practice.
Keywords: Juvenile Justice, Reformative Theory, Rehabilitation, Children in Conflict with Law, Criminology, Institutional Reality
Introduction: Juvenile delinquency has emerged as one of the most debated issues within contemporary criminology and criminal justice administration. The increasing involvement of children in crimes such as theft, assault, drug-related offences, cybercrime, and violent offences has raised concerns regarding the effectiveness of juvenile justice institutions in India.
The philosophical foundation of juvenile justice rests upon the belief that children possess greater capacity for behavioural change and social reintegration. Consequently, juvenile justice laws across the world focus on counselling, education, psychological support, vocational training, and social rehabilitation. India adopted this welfare-oriented approach through various legislations culminating in the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.
However, despite progressive legislative frameworks, serious concerns continue to exist regarding the actual functioning of juvenile justice institutions. Observation homes and special homes frequently suffer from overcrowding, inadequate infrastructure, lack of trained staff, poor mental healthcare support, and insufficient rehabilitation programmes.
Research Objectives: The research objectives of this study are as:
- To examine the reformative philosophy underlying juvenile justice administration in India.
- To analyse the institutional functioning of juvenile homes and rehabilitation mechanisms.
- To evaluate practical challenges affecting implementation of juvenile justice laws.
- To study perceptions of stakeholders regarding rehabilitation and reintegration.
- To suggest reforms for strengthening juvenile justice administration.
Research Questions: The research questions are as:
- To what extent does juvenile justice administration in India reflect reformative principles?
- What are the major institutional challenges faced by juvenile justice institutions?
- Does the existing system adequately rehabilitate children in conflict with law?
- What reforms are necessary for effective juvenile rehabilitation?
Research Methodology: For this study, the researcher adopted doctrinal and empirical methodologies. For doctrinal study, statutes, judicial decisions, academic literature, committee reports, NCRB reports, and international instruments relating to juvenile justice were analysed. For this study, the researcher has collected the qualitative responses from stakeholders associated with juvenile justice administration including:
.jpeg)
